Sally, When the Wine Runs Out” – Role Model’s Fallon Performance Was a Milestone Worth Watching

Last night on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, Role Model — best known as Tucker Pillsbury — brought his once tiny world into the spotlight with a performance that felt both like a celebration and a statement. As someone who’s been a fan of Tucker for almost five years now, watching him perform “Sally, When the Wine Runs Out” felt intimate, electric, and unmistakably him. Saint Laurent Cowboy definitely wanted to make an appearance a few times, but Role Model kept his cool for the night.

If you, like me, have been following Role Model for a while, you know how far he’s come — from his moody, bedroom pop beginnings to these fully realized performances that blur the lines between music and storytelling. This Fallon moment was proof of that growth. From opening for Omar Apollo, to headlining his own tour, then opening for Gracie Abrams, and now headlining again — it’s all been building to moments like this.

He didn’t just sing a song; he invited the world into a kind of tradition he’s cultivated on tour. “Where’s my Sally tonight?” he always asks. This time, it was SNL’s Bowen Yang stepping into the role, dancing beside Tucker like he’d always belonged there.

But Tucker doesn’t do this just for show. It’s clear how much he values connection — and how he strays away from taking things too seriously. From inviting friends and fellow artists like Reneé Rapp, Dylan Minnette, and Laufey, to even having his mom as Sally at the final show in Boston (because let’s be real — there’s no place like Boston), everything about his performances radiates fun, heart, and togetherness.

This tour — and getting to open for Gracie Abrams — clearly means a lot to him. In his recent tour diary, Tucker says, “I think it’ll pay off, I’m excited, hopefully all this work is not for nothing.” And honestly? It’s not. Every dance, every goofy moment, every camera snipe from Neema — it all feels like something real he’s building. And now, the world is watching.

This wasn’t just another late-night appearance. It felt like a true payoff — for him, for longtime fans, and for anyone who’s followed his journey, whether from the beginning or just recently. Role Model’s Fallon performance wasn’t just a big moment — it was a reminder that vulnerability and connection do matter. And yeah, it’s definitely paying off.

Video courtesy of The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon / NBC.

Leave a comment